The Iron Giant (1999)

B+ SDG Original source: National Catholic Register

One of the pinnacles of non-Disney American animation, Brad Bird’s The Iron Giant is a nostalgic fantasy in the spirit of E.T. about a young boy (Eli Marienthal) growing up in a fatherless house, whose unusual friendship with a being from outer space — here a giant robot (Vin Diesel) with a penchant for eating metal — has to be hidden from his mom (Jennifer Aniston) and the federal government.

Buy at
1999, Warner Bros. Directed by Brad Bird. Jennifer Aniston, Harry Connick Jr. Animated.

Artistic/Entertainment Value

Moral/Spiritual Value

+2 / -1

Age Appropriateness

Kids & Up*

MPAA Rating


Caveat Spectator

Large-scale animated violence; some rough language and profanity.

Eschewing song-and-dance numbers and cute animal sidekicks, the film’s appeal comes from its winsome characters, its resonant story, and its evocative sense of time and place — in this case New England in the days of Sputnik and "duck and cover" drills.

Remarkably, despite an action-packed finale, Iron Giant manages an anti-violence message that’s more than mere lip service. Yet young Hogarth’s moralizing is overly glib, not only in attributing a soul to his mechanical friend (which could be excused in a fantasy) but also in applying his "Killing is wrong" lesson to deer hunting (which can’t).

Still, the film’s strengths overshadow these weaknesses, and Iron Giant goes beyond the non-redemptive Christological resonances of E.T. (note: spoilers ahead) as the misunderstood, persecuted title character willingly sacrifices himself to save others, then is miraculously reborn.

Animation, Comedy, Family, Science Fiction, Top Movie Moms